COMMUNITY-BASED TOURISM AS A SUSTAINABLE SCHEME? HIDDEN PARADOX FROM THE CASE STUDY IN THUYBIEU WARD, HUE CITY

Keywords

community-based tourism
central Vietnam
sustainable development
local community

Abstract

Community-based tourism (CBT) emerged as a form of anti-mass tourism because of its economic, social, and environmental benefits. This study examines whether CBT is faithful to those promises in reality. The research was carried out in Thuybieu ward, which is considered a famous CBT destination in Hue city, central Vietnam. By using the interpretive approach and qualitative methods, the results show that CBT started in the 2010s with the participation of small local groups and business startups. CBT then rapidly developed with the involvement and over control from private outsiders, resulting in elite capture, non-authenticity issues, and imbalance in benefit-sharing. The results also shed light on the truth that business agencies called for the community’s participation under the guise of sustainable development and community benefits that lead to risks for the community themself and changed the nature of CBT theory. Recognizing this, the study proposes policy implications towards a more sustainable and equitable development in the context of CBT.

https://doi.org/10.26459/hueunijard.v130i3C.6140

References

  1. T. B. Jamal and D. Getz (1995), Collaboration theory and community tourism planning, Ann. Tour. Res., 22(1), 186–204.
  2. A. Buanes, S. Jentoft, A. Maurstad, S. U. Søreng, and G. Runar Karlsen (2005), Stakeholder participation in Norwegian coastal zone planning, Ocean Coast. Manag., 48(9–10), 658–669.
  3. L. S. Sebele (2010), Community-based tourism ventures, benefits and challenges: Khama Rhino Sanctuary Trust, Central District, Botswana, Tour. Manag., 31(1), 136–146.
  4. A. Hardy, R. J. S. Beeton, and L. Pearson (2002), Sustainable tourism: An overview of the concept and its position in relation to conceptualisations of tourism, J. Sustain. Tour., 10(6), 475–496.
  5. D. A. Fennell (2005), Ecotourism , second edition, Routledge.
  6. T. López-Guzmán, S. Sánchez-Cañizares, and V. Pavón (2011), Community - based tourism in developing countries: A case study, Tourismos, 6(1), 69–84.
  7. T. H. Lee and F. H. Jan (2019), Can community-based tourism contribute to sustainable development? Evidence from residents’ perceptions of the sustainability, Tour. Manag., 70, no. September 2018, 368–380.
  8. F. A. Putri and N. C. Adinia (2018), The Role of Communication in Sustainable Development Tourism : A Case Study on Community-based Tourism ( Pokdarwis ) in Nglanggeran Village,” J. Komun. Indones., VII(2), 153–161.
  9. S. L. Wearing, M. Wearing, and M. McDonald (2010), Understanding local power and interactional processes in sustainable tourism: Exploring village-tour operator relations on the Kokoda Track, Papua New Guinea, J. Sustain. Tour., 18(1), 61–76.
  10. H. Goodwin and R. Santilli (2009), Community-Based Tourism: a success?, ICRT Occas. Pap., 11, 1–37.
  11. J. Brohman (1996), New directions in tourism for third world development, Ann. Tour. Res., 23(1), 48–70.
  12. J. E. Mbaiwa and A. L. Stronza (2010), The effects of tourism development on rural livelihoods in the Okavango Delta, Botswana, J. Sustain. Tour.,
  13. M. Wells, K. Brandon, and L. Hannah (1992), People and Parks: Linking protected area management with local community, The Worldbank.
  14. UNWTO (2017), Tourism and the Sustainable Development Goals – Journey to 2030.
  15. V. M. Cuong (2020), Alienation of ethnic minorities in community-based tourism, Curr. Issues Tour., 23(21), 2649–2665.
  16. N. Q. Tan, U. Fumikazu, and N. C. Dinh (2019), Development Process of the Community-based Tourism: From Two Case Studies in Central Vietnam, in Vietnam – Japan Science and Technology Symposium (VJST2019), 124–128.
  17. L. T. N. Hoa (2012), Ecotourism development - The case of Vietnam, Doctoral Thesis, The University of Queensland.
  18. T. Ngo, G. Lohmann, and R. Hales (2018), Collaborative marketing for the sustainable development of community-based tourism enterprises: voices from the field, J. Sustain. Tour., 26(8), 1325–1343.
  19. UNWTO (2018), Tourism Highlights 2018 Edition International Tourism Trends 2017, 1–20.
  20. W. Suntikul et al. (2016), Impacts of tourism on the quality of life of local residents in Hue, Vietnam, Anatolia, 27(4), 405–420.
  21. D. B. Weaver (2001), Principles of Ecotourism.
  22. M. Oishi (2016), Contemporary Conflicts in Southeast Asia: Towards a New ASEAN Way of Conflict Management.
  23. N. Lipscombe and R. I. K. Thwaites (2003), Contemporary Challenges for Ecotourism in Vietnam, Tour. Rev. Int., 7(1), 23–35.
  24. J. Michaud and S. Turner (2017), Reaching new heights. State legibility in Sa Pa, a Vietnam hill station, Ann. Tour. Res., 66, 37–48, 2017.
  25. M. Hitchcock, K. T. Voictor, and M. Parnwwell (2010), Heritage Tourism in Southeast Asia.
  26. V. D. Truong (2013), Tourism policy development in Vietnam: A pro-poor perspective, J. Policy Res. Tour. Leis. Events, 5, 1, 28–45.
  27. W. Kibicho (2008), Community-based tourism: A factor-cluster segmentation approach, J. Sustain. Tour., 16, 2, 211–231.
  28. E. H. Zube and M. L. Busch (1990), Park-people relationships: an international review, Landsc. Urban Plan., 19(2), 117–131.
  29. R. Phillips and S. Roberts (2013), Tourism, Planning, and Community Development, Routledge.
  30. S. Harris (2000), Reconciling positive and interpretative international management research: A native category approach, Int. Bus. Rev., 9(6), 755–770.
  31. D. MacCannell (1999), The Tourist: A new theory of the leisure class, University of California Press.
  32. H. A. C. Thái (2018), Livelihood Pathways of Indigenous People in Vietnam ’ s Central Highlands. Springer Nature.
  33. C. Tosun (2000), Limits to community participation in the tourism development process in developing countries, Tour. Manag., 21(6), 613–633.
  34. D. M. Ngila (2009), The private sector-community relationship in ecotourism: The case of Umngazi river bungalows, Esastern Cape, Master's Thesis, University of Kwazulu-Natal, South Africa.
  35. C. Tosun (1998), Roots of unsustainable tourism development at the local level: The case of Urgup in Turkey, Tour. Manag., 19(6), 595–610.
  36. USAID (2018), Strategic development of ecotourism in Quang Nam and Thua Thien Hue provinces, period 2018–2023 (in Vietnamese), In green annamites project, support by USAID.
  37. The People’s Committee of Thua Thien Hue Province (2017), Final report of research on development of payment for forest environment services for tourism business in Thua Thien Hue province (in Vietnamese).
  38. The People’s committee of Thua Thien Hue province (2019), policies relate to community-based tourism in Thua Thien Hue province, Retrieved from https://thuathienhue.gov.vn
  39. N. Q. Tan, U. Fumikazu, N. C. Dinh, and D.V. Tan (2019), Current status and limits during the community-based tourism development in moutainous areas of A Luoi district, Thua Thien Hue province, Can Tho University Journal of Science (CTUJS), 55(1), 157–166.
  40. Department of Tourism in Thua Thien Hue, Synthesize tourist statistics in Thua Hue province for the period 2010–2019.
  41. People’s committee of Thuybieu commune, Socio-economic annual report in 2017 and development strategy in 2018.